2019 — Jarod Bowie, Martinsburg

2018 — Graeson Malashevich, Spring Valley (KR-PR)
2017 — George Triplett, Elkins (PK)
2016 — Cason Kessinger, Huntington (PK)
2015 — Evan Staley, Hampshire (PK)
2014 — Deonte Glover, Musselman (KR/PR)