2019 — Adam Murray, sr., Wheeling Central (LB)

2018 — Adam Murray, jr., Wheeling Central (LB) 
2017 — Adam Murray, soph., Wheeling Central (LB)
2016 — Tavis Lee, jr., Martinsburg (DE)
2015 — Reese Donahue, Cabell Midland (DL)
2014 — Isaiah Honesty, Martinsburg (LB)
2013 — Geremy Paige, Wheeling Park (LB)
2012 — Elijah Wellman, Spring Valley (LB)
2011 — Logan Jenkins, Martinsburg (LB)
2010 — Ryan Lazear, Brooke (LB)
2009 — Alex Sutton, Bridgeport (LB)
2008 — Aaron Slusher, South Charleston (LB)
2007 — Rodney Hudson, jr., G. Washington (DL)
2006 — Xavier Peters, Martinsburg (DB)
2005 — Adam Parkulo, Woodrow Wilson (LB)
2004 — Zac Cooper, Weir (LB)
2003 — Ben Gum, Parkersburg South (LB)
2002 — Will Albin, Princeton (LB)
2001 — Joey Spano, George Washington (LB)
2000 — Ashley McNeely, Wyoming East (LB)
1999 — Al Hammell, Parkersburg (LB)
1998 — Eric Grimm, Parkersburg (S)
1997 — Ben Collins, North Marion (LB)
1996 — Yubrenal Isabelle Bluefield (LB)
1995 — Nathan Kirby, Parkersburg (LB)
1994 — Bobbie Howard DuPont (LB)